Jordan Gelber

Ira

Bridget Barkan

Joleen

Stephen McKinley Henderson

Arthur

Sydnee Stewart

Erin Persaud

Craig muMs Grant

Ali

Marsin Mogielski

Restaurant Patron (uncredited)

Billoah Greene

Samel

Polly Humphreys

Shirley

Victor Pagan

Victor

Reg E. Cathey

Akbar

Steve Axelrod

Sol

Iris Little Thomas

Erin's Mother

Ron Butler

Ron Harding

Donna Vivino

Samel's Caseworker

Erin Dilly

Arianna

Marc Anthony Thompson

Marc

David Brummel

Ira's Father

Earl Baker Jr.

Benjamin

Lou Martini Jr.

Mr. Califano

Candice Sanchez McFarlane

Mel

Dante Nero

Biker

Warner Miller

Beadie

Ramon Fernandez

Chico

Jamie Hector

Devon

Omar A. Soriano

Omar

Kalimi Baxter

Ruby

Garry Pastore

V.

Tom Gilroy

Erin's Professor

Jack A. O'Connell

John

Erik LaRay Harvey

Bartender

Verna O. Hobson

Lady with Blue Drink

David Barroso

Customer with Cellphone

Nathan De'Shon Myers

Subway Opera Singer

Kadijah Carlisle

Benita

Stephanie Berry

Angry Black Waitress

Frantz Cineotra

Frantz

Stacie Linardos

Angry White Waitress

Elizabeth Flax

Female Customer

Freddie L. King

Subway Doo Wop Singer #1

Charles Vickers

Subway Doo Wop Singer #2