Christian Slater

Charlie "Lucky" Luciano

Patrick Dempsey

Meyer Lansky

Richard Grieco

Benjamin "Bugsy" Siegel

Costas Mandylor

Frank Costello

F. Murray Abraham

Arnold Rothstein

Lara Flynn Boyle

Mara Motes

Michael Gambon

Don Salvatore Faranzano

Chris Penn

Tommy Reina

Anthony Quinn

Don Giuseppe 'Joe the Boss' Masseria

Rodney Eastman

Joey

Robert Z'Dar

Rocco

Seymour Cassel

Father Bonotto

Andy Romano

Antonio Luciano

Bianca Rossini

Rosalie Luciano

Joe Viterelli

Joe Profaci

Leslie Bega

Anna Lansky

Titus Welliver

Al Capone

Russ Fega

Nathan Citron

Leonard Termo

Joe Palermo

Lynette Walden

Cute Debutante

Sharmagne Leland-St. John

Wedding Guest

Anto Nolan

Irish Cop

Jennifer Gatti

Secretary

Ava Fabian

Cute Girl

Jeremy Schoenberg

Crapshooter

Miles Perlich

Crapshooter

Alan Charof

Rabbi

Sean San Jose

Another Italian

Karen Russell

Showgirl

Bryan Law

Irish Thug

Clark Heathcliffe Brolly

Mike Shane

Trish Steele

Costello's Mother

Emile Nicolaou

Kid

Fyvush Finkel

Tailor

Russell Curry

Black Gangster

Carmen Twillie

Blues Singer

Don Brockett

Irish Politician

Anya Longwell

Showgirl

Monique Noel

Showgirl

Nicholas Sadler

Mad Dog Coll