Glenn Close

Diana

Elizabeth Banks

Isabel

Eric Bogosian

Henry

Jesse Bradford

Alec

Matthew Davis

Mark

Andrew Howard

Ian

Thomas Lennon

Marshall

John Light

Peter

Susan Malick

Rachel

James Marsden

Jonathan

Michael Murphy

Jesse

Denis O'Hare

Andrew

Isabella Rossellini

Liz

George Segal

Rabbi Mendel

Rufus Wainwright

Jeremy

Angel Desai

Laura

Katie Kreisler

Helen

Regina Schneider

Amanda

Jim Parsons

Oliver

Philip Tabor

Paul

Jonathan Walker

Michael

Chandler Williams

Juilliard Macbeth

Bess Wohl

Juilliard Lady Macbeth

Daniel Neiden

Wedding Rabbi

Rachel Siegel

Autograph Seeker

Jordi Vilasuso

Benjamin's Ex

Nat DeWolf

Benjamin's Ex

Joel de la Fuente

Benjamin's Ex

Melanie R. Orr

Scorned Woman

Jane Nichols

Guest 1

Don Fitzgerald

Built Guy

Meghan Glennon

Party Girl

Winsome Brown

SNL Writer

Michael Goldstrom

SNL Writer

Steven Glenn

Guest 2

Alice Tan Ridley

Subway Singer

Caroline Clay

Subway Woman

Cindy Adams

Self

Alexander Lange

Guest 3

Manny Siverio

Subway Mugger