Kristy Swanson

Buffy Summers

Donald Sutherland

Merrick Jamison-Smythe

Paul Reubens

Amilyn

Rutger Hauer

Lothos

Luke Perry

Oliver Pike

Hilary Swank

Kimberly Hannah

Michele Abrams

Jennifer

David Arquette

Benny

Natasha Gregson Wagner

Cassandra

Thomas Jane

Zeph

Ricki Lake

Charlotte

Stephen Root

Gary Murray

Sasha Jenson

Grueller

Candy Clark

Buffy's Mom

Paris Vaughan

Nicole 'Nicki'

Randall Batinkoff

Jeffrey

Andrew Lowery

Andy

Mark DeCarlo

Coach

James Paradise

Buffy's Dad

David Sherrill

Knight

Paul M. Lane

Robert Berman

Toby Holguin

Vampire Fan

Eurlyne Epper

Graveyard Woman

Andre Warren

Newscaster

Bob Swanson

Referee

Erika Dittner

Cheerleader

J.T. Cole

Biker

Michael Kopelow

Student

Ricky Dean Logan

Bloody Student

Bobby Aldridge

Vampire

Amanda Anka

Vampire

Chino Binamo

Vampire

Al Goto

Vampire

Terry Jackson

Vampire

Mike Johnson

Vampire

Sarah Lee Jones

Vampire

Kim Robert Koscki

Vampire

Clint Lilley

Vampire

Chi Muoi Lo

Vampire

Jimmy N. Roberts

Vampire