Steven Yeun

Bo (voice)

Gina Rodriguez

Mary (voice)

Zachary Levi

Joseph (voice)

Keegan-Michael Key

Dave (voice)

Kelly Clarkson

Leah (voice)

Anthony Anderson

Zach (voice)

Kris Kristofferson

Old Donkey (voice)

Ving Rhames

Thaddeus (voice)

Gabriel Iglesias

Rufus (voice)

Patricia Heaton

Edith (voice)

Kristin Chenoweth

Abby (voice)

Christopher Plummer

King Herod (voice)

Aidy Bryant

Ruth (voice)

Tyler Perry

Cyrus (voice)

Tracy Morgan

Felix (voice)

Oprah Winfrey

Deborah (voice)

Mariah Carey

Rebecca (voice)

Phil Morris

Balthazar /Miller (voice)

Fred Tatasciore

Melchior / Inn keeper #1 / Pottery Vendor (voice)

Gregg Berger

Inn Keeper #3 (voice)

Joel Osteen

Caspar (voice)

Lex Lang

Hunter (voice)

Melissa Sturm

Inn Keeper #4 (voice)

Roger Craig Smith

Chamberlain / Inn Keeper #5 (voice)

Kari Wahlgren

Additional Voices (voice)

William Townsend

Horse / Goat (voice)

Stephen Apostolina

Additional Voices (voice)

Kirk Baily

Additional Voices (voice)

David Cowgill

Additional Voices (voice)

June Christopher

Additional Voices (voice)

Eddie Frierson

Additional Voices (voice)

Rif Hutton

Additional Voices (voice)

Mona Marshall

Additional Voices (voice)

Caitlin McKenna

Additional Voices (voice)

Scott Menville

Additional Voices (voice)

Warren Sroka

Additional Voices (voice)

Pepper Sweeney

Additional Voices (voice)

Grant George

Additional Voices (voice)

Bridget Hoffman

Additional Voices (voice)

Moira Quirk

Additional Voices (voice)