James Stewart

Marshal Guthrie McCabe

Richard Widmark

First Lt. Jim Gary

Shirley Jones

Marty Purcell

Linda Cristal

Elena de la Madriaga

Andy Devine

Sgt. Darius P. Posey

John McIntire

Major Frazer

Paul Birch

Judge Edward Purcell

Willis Bouchey

Mr. Harry J. Wringle

Henry Brandon

Chief Quanah Parker

Harry Carey Jr.

Ortho Clegg

Olive Carey

Mrs. Abby Frazer

Ken Curtis

Greeley Clegg

Chet Douglas

Deputy Ward Corby

Annelle Hayes

Belle Aragon

David Kent

Running Wolf

Anna Lee

Mrs. Malaprop

Jeanette Nolan

Mrs. Mary McCandless

John Qualen

Ole Knudsen

Ford Rainey

Rev. Henry Clegg

Woody Strode

Stone Calf

O.Z. Whitehead

Lt. Whitehead

Chuck Roberson

Comanche

Gertrude Astor

Mrs. Wringle (uncredited)

Bobette Bentley

Minor Role (uncredited)

Bill Borzage

Settler (uncredited)

Danny Borzage

Trooper (uncredited)

Jim Brewer

Jack (uncredited)

Regina Carrol

Wakanana (uncredited)

Ruth Clifford

Woman (uncredited)

Jane Crowley

Settler (uncredited)

Tony Dante

Settler (uncredited)

George Fisher

Bartender (uncredited)

Rian Garrick

Lieutenant Upton (uncredited)

Eunice Grey

Mother of Indian Stolen Child (uncredited)

Signe Hack

Settler (uncredited)

Big John Hamilton

Settler (uncredited)

Janet Hamilton

Girl (uncredited)

Sam Harris

Post Doctor (uncredited)

Chuck Hayward

Trooper (uncredited)

William Henry

Gambler (uncredited)